jump to navigation

A Scientist Scoffs at “Scientific Fact” April 28, 2009

Posted by markgeil in Academia, Philosophical musings.
add a comment

I am grading final papers in one of my classes. So far, they’re pretty good, although I still see some of the superfluous absolutes that seem to pop up in student papers. I’ll see a statement like, “Robinson et al. (2009) proved that collateral ligament injury is caused by…” and out comes the red pen. I’ll cross out the word “proved” and replace it with a more benign word, like “demonstrated”. Scientific theories and experiments are what they are: limited ideas or demonstrations of a principle in a given context. That’s why I’m amused when a body like the National Academy of Sciences declares that a theory like evolution has been studied enough that we might as well call it fact. That’s also why I chuckle at the following from the most recent Time magazine:

When a scientific principle is common knowledge even in grammar schools, you know it’s long since crossed the line from theory to established fact. That’s the case with dinosaur extinction. Some 65 million years ago – as we’ve all come to know – an asteroid struck the Earth, sending up a cloud that blocked the sun and cooled the planet. That, in turn, wiped out the dinosaurs and made way for the rise of the mammals. The suddenness with which so many species vanished after the 65-million-year mark always suggested a single cataclysmic event, and the 1978 discovery of a 112-mi., 65-million-year-old crater off the Yucatán peninsula near the town of Chicxulub seemed to seal the deal.

Now, however, a new study in the Journal of the Geological Society throws all of that into question.

The title of the article is, “Maybe an Asteroid Didn’t Kill the Dinosaurs.” My translation: “Maybe we don’t know jack.” Just because we study something a lot, and talk about it a lot, our theories will still be theories, and our proofs of theories will be proven in the limited context of the experiment offering “proof”. Meanwhile, God is God and I am not, and He knows how wrong we are about some of our scientific “fact”.

A Trip to India April 27, 2009

Posted by markgeil in Compassion.
Tags: ,
add a comment

Actually, I’m going on a trip to Seattle, and mine is just for work. A far more interesting trip is going on right now with the Compassion Bloggers in India:

http://compassionbloggers.com/trips

This is a group of writers visiting Compassion projects in India to provide us with a firsthand look at the faces of poverty and the good work that’s being done there. Stop by for a visit!

Behind the Scenes at GMA Week Part 7 April 22, 2009

Posted by markgeil in Music.
2 comments

Another morning, another unusual breakfast. This was the media breakfast for the Provident label group, held at the Hard Rock Café. I was seated a couple of the guys from Jars of Clay and Dawn from Fireflight, along with the editor of CCM magazine. We enjoyed getting to know one another, got a preview of a new project from Mac Powell, watched a hilarious video introducing the Aussie group Revive, complete with Men at Work covers, and saw a few tremendous acoustic performances. Hats off especially to Phil Stacey (the American Idol guy), who performed a cover of the Rich Mullins song I thought no one would ever ever cover, “Hard to Get”, and to Jars of Clay, who performed “Two Hands” from their new album. Then a person in an astronaut costume brought them a cake to celebrate the album release. How odd.

By the way, although I got the Jars album a day early, I didn’t listen to it until yesterday, and let me say this: It’s brilliant. Absolutely brilliant. I wish I had listened to it Monday night so I could gush to the guys Tuesday morning, but I was quite busy.

Yes, Monday night. Here’s a concert for you: TobyMac and the Diverse City Band, Mandisa, Tommy Sims, B. Reith, Angelo and Veronica, Amy Grant, Israel Houghton, a surprise appearance by Jonny Lang, a whole bunch of others I can’t remember, and the one I really wanted to see, Phil Keaggy. That was ONE CONCERT. This was my first time seeing Mr. Keaggy (Sir Keaggy?) live. You know how you can wait your whole life to see someone and have such lofty expectations that there’s no way the person can actually live up to those expectations? Well, that was me, and well, Phil DID live up to my expectations. Nay, he blew them away. He performed “While My Guitar Gently Weeps” followed by the extended, free-flowing acoustic jam I’ve always wanted to see from the master of the guitar.

I took off from there to another club to catch Lanae Hale, Matt Pappa, and downhere. I’ve been a big downhere fan for years but have also never seen them live. The vocal tandem in this band is hard to beat, and the songwriting continues to excel. Their latest album is just right for these times, and I also recommend it highly.

I did my extended interviews with Israel Houghton and Phil Stacey on Tuesday morning. Both were engaging and articulate, and both expressed a pastor’s heart. I’ll give you a heads up when these stories run.

More stories, and hopefully some audio and pictures, to come. WordPress keeps telling me I don’t have the rights to upload audio that I’ve recorded, all by myself, on my own recorder. Pretty pushy of WordPress, methinks. Any blog experts know what I might be doing wrong?

Bonus April 20, 2009

Posted by markgeil in Music.
Tags:
add a comment

I talked with Andrew Peterson again this morning, and then while we shared a 23-story elevator ride I mentioned that I had stolen his song title for the name of this blog. He was okay with that. What’s cooler is that he already knew about the blog from my link to the Rabbit Room. I’m livin’ large.

Behind the Scenes at GMA Week Part 6 April 20, 2009

Posted by markgeil in Music.
Tags: ,
add a comment

The energy has been maintained. I’m writing at 10:30 on Monday morning. The crowds are still picking up here, although everyone says how there are fewer people everywhere compared to years past. I have no means of comparison. The only thing I keep mentally comparing GMA Week to is the typical sort of conference I attend as part of my day job as a prof. I attend meetings of groups like the American Society of Biomechanics, and I see old friends, and meet lots of people, and learn new things. Essentially the same things happen here, except instead of passing curmudgeonly engineers on the escalator, I pass groups of four 20-something guys clad all in black with way too much eyeliner. Plus, at my engineering meetings I don’t usually SCHOOL MARK SCHULTZ AT PING PONG!

 

That’s right, it was Mark vs. Mark this morning, and this here Mark triumphed. Schultzy (can I call him that?) was tough in the warm up, and made a fierce comeback halfway through, but I sealed the win on a wicked forehand that bounced off the edge of the back corner of the table. Schultzy said, “Does that count?” I replied, “Oh yes,” and raised my hands in victory. After the Curb walkout yesterday, I think I’ve now all but destroyed my chances of a record deal. Alas.

 

I met Matthew West for breakfast and we had a great chat. Then I interviewed Andrew Peterson and we got to get off topic and talk about Rich Mullins. Seriously, I could do that all day.

I stopped into a session on Radio. I arrived at the Q&A time. A room full of questions from people with great DJ voices. Amusing.

I’ve got to go to another hotel to the Gotee Suite for my 11:00. I also don’t usually go to the Gotee Suite at my engineering meetings.

Behind the Scenes at GMA Week Part 5 April 19, 2009

Posted by markgeil in Music.
2 comments

It occurred to me that these are not really “Behind the Scenes” updates. In fact, I haven’t been behind a single scene since I’ve been here. I supposed they should be called “In front of the scenes” updates. Alas, you start with a name and you’re stuck with it.

It’s Sunday now at 5:30. Things are picking up in the hotel with a steady stream of arrivals. Radio stations are setting up fully functional glassed-in portable studios for live broadcasts. Christian music is now being pumped through the hotel’s speakers, which is kinda fun.

Last night I partied at a Promoter’s showcase at Rocketown. Unless you’re old like me , the following exchange won’t mean much, but for the rest of us, here’s what dated me. I was being given a tour of the facilities by one of the friendly young people who work there. She asked if I already knew much about Rocketown. I said that I mostly knew the song. See, Michael W. Smith wrote this song 100 years ago about a seedy bar called Rocketown that all the locals would frequent and a kindly preacher man who stood outside and told the patrons about God. So, when Smitty decided to open a safe facility for young people, he called it Rocketown, after the cool name in the song. When I told my tour guide that was pretty much all I knew about Rocketown, she replied, “Yeah, I had heard there was a song. I’ve never heard it. Do you know what it’s actually about?” Egad! I thought the song would be on a continuous loop on loudspeakers throughout the facility and the surrounding streets, and she had NEVER HEARD IT! Something must be done about this. Immediately. I’m serious.

Evening culminated in the North American debut performance of Bluetree, the newish band from Belfast. They wrote “God of this City”, which Chris Tomlin covered on his latest album. Great show. I got to chat with the guys this morning, and they have a refreshing earnestness. The guitarist is 19 years old. My oldest daughter is 15. I really am that old. He’s probably never heard the Rocketown song either.

Got to the hotel about 1:00 and crashed, with the pleasure of not even setting the alarm, since Sunday morning worship was at 10:00 and I couldn’t sleep that late if I stayed up until 9 am. That Sunday morning worship was a powerful experience. Matt Redman led the music, with overqualified backup by Christy Nockels. I got a repeat performance of the new song I heard at the Good Friday show, and I still love it. There’s also a particular joy of being in a room of so many brilliant singers. I think there was 4-part harmony during “Everlasting God.” Louie Giglio preached on Psalm 40 and told the moving tale of Ashley’s Diary, which you can probably find somewhere if you haven’t heard it.

The first of only four interviews followed. In between I got the chance to go over to the Music City Walk of Fame induction ceremony. They hold it every year in conjunction with GMA Week. It’s a “stars on the sidewalk” thing like in Hollywood. The ceremony was moved indoors this year since it’s rainy. I intended to just pop my head in, but I somehow got checked in as “Media” and wound up a little bit stuck with a bunch of photographers and very famous music people in a very crowded room at the Sommet Center. That only became a problem when it was time for my next interview, and I had no escape. I wound up having to walk out in the middle of a speech my Mike Curb, one of the most influential people in music today. There goes my chances of getting signed to Curb Records and becoming the next Tim McGraw. I did quite enjoy getting a full hour to marvel at Marty Stuart’s hair. I wished Mom and Dad could have been there, because there were some country music folks there they would have really enjoyed seeing.

Dinner with a group of publicists is next, then possibly a songwriters showcase, then moving to the next hotel, then breakfast with Matthew West tomorrow morning. I have six big interviews tomorrow. I hope I can maintain the energy!

Behind the Scenes at GMA Week Part 4 April 18, 2009

Posted by markgeil in Music.
Tags: ,
add a comment

Interview with Mr. Styll was excellent, as expected. He’s the one who can speak with authority on how economic trends are affecting the industry. Hard data, not just scuttlebutt. I am now sitting in the Starbucks off the hotel lobby, hoping in vain to find the mysterious WiFi that showed up for a few brief hours this morning and pleased that I was able to use the word “Scuttlebutt” in a sentence. I’m enjoying watching the parade of guitar-toting rock stars arrive and stand in the registration line. There are lots of torn jeans in the house. GMA should hire a seamstress. Shirts with printed pictures of feathery things are also everywhere. And indoor sunglasses. And those toasty warm knit beanie hats, even though it’s not that cold. And we’re inside.

Oh, and I also learned that on Monday I can play ping pong against Mark Schultz. I’m in!

Behind the Scenes at GMA Week Part 3 April 18, 2009

Posted by markgeil in Music.
Tags: ,
add a comment

Rats.  It wasn’t Fernando, at least not in person. They’re testing sound while they set up one of the ballrooms for a showcase tonight. Why they chose a Fernando song to do a sound check, I don’t know, but I admire their taste.

 

Back to my stories. After the live song-rating, I caught the last few minutes of a talk by Jim Morgan, the President and CEO of Krispy Kreme Dougnuts, perhaps the world’s finest food. His message was riveting. No slides or visuals, nothing fancy, just even and deliberate life lessons from a man with an abundance of experience. And yes, he brought doughnuts. Mmmmm.

 

The vendors are setting up their displays. Some are missions. Others are services for musicians, like production and promotion. Some of the indies who got good reviews might be stopping by a booth or two. I’m off now to meet with John Styll, the president of this whole GMA thing. He should have much to offer for my story on the economy and its effects on Christian music.

Behind the Scenes at GMA Week Part 2 April 18, 2009

Posted by markgeil in Music.
Tags: ,
1 comment so far

The Boulevard of Lived-Out Dreams

 

I just took a stroll down Broadway, the Nashville variety. Since the lonesome cowboy I saw by dawn’s early light, I’ve passed five or six guitar-toting pedestrians. They’re probably headed to Broadway. It’s still broad daylight, but every single bar has a live music act. To walk down either side of the street is to turn the dial on some ambient radio, to hear an ever-changing playlist of mostly country music, much of it original, most of it really good. Most of the stages are on the street side, so passers-by can gawk at the rear ends of earnest performers who must be living out their dreams. Yes, these are bars. They’re smoky, and a little ragged (well, a lot ragged, some of them), but they’re in Nashville, on Broadway, and I’m certain that a few of the guitar-toting pedestrians wish they could be in one of those ragged bars one day.

 

The Indie musicians in this afternoon’s session all have their own aspirations, and the live critiques by the radio promoters were fascinating. A song would play – well, part of a song. Only had time for first verse and chorus. The artist would be somewhere in the room, but would not be identified. I couldn’t help looking around when the songs would start, wondering whose budding career was on display. Most had pretty god poker faces. Some critiques were very encouraging. Great voice, hooked from the first line of the lyrics, needs a better mix and this might be ready for radio – that sort of thing. Others were probably disappointing. Lots of complaints about percussion. Drummers and sound engineers, take note. Apparently mic-ing and recording drums is not easy.

 

A Fernadno Ortega song that I really like just started. I’m tempted to go find the source, but I don’t think I’ll have time before my 4:30 interview. Oh, why not? I’m going to find Fernando Ortega.

 

Behind the Scenes at GMA Week April 18, 2009

Posted by markgeil in Music.
add a comment

It’s Saturday morning, and I’m in Nashville for GMA Week. GMA is the Gospel Music Association, and they cover just about all types of Christian music. This is their annual week-long meeting, and it leads up to the Dove Awards, the Christian music equivalent to the Grammy Awards. This is my first time here, and for years I’ve wanted to read an account of what goes on this week. So, I’m planning to post what I’ve always wanted to read myself. Here’s the first dispatch. These will be pretty rough and unedited!

 

Drove into sleepy Nashville Saturday morning. At the first exit, shortly after sunrise , waiting to cross the street, was a man with a Starbucks cup, a cowboy hat, and an old guitar slung across his shoulder. I love it! Welcome to Nash-Vegas!

Most of downtown stoplights are on blink, still not awake. I just drove by a statue of Billy Graham.

There’s an All-State chorus at this hotel this weekend as well. Lots of kids are running around in matching polos. It’s interesting to see to goofy exuberance of these young singers amidst so many accomplished veterans.

I walked past Country Music Disk Jockey hall of fame to convention center for registration.

8:12 am. Just met Andrew Peterson, one of my musical heroes. Good start. I think I rescued him from some long-haired dude telling AP a little too much information about the nervous breakdown he had before he started his new musical career. Lots of new musical careers here. I like the energy.

 Lots of people with “The Look” – outfits carefully chosen to look like they weren’t carefully chosen.

Right now I’m in a room full of Indie artists. A fortunate few are going to play a single track for a panel of radio promoters for live feedback in a room full of their peers. That takes a lot of courage. Being a performing musician takes courage in the first place. You are placing yourself out there, for everyone to take and consume and judge.  The people in this room are palpably engaged in how to figure out this industry, but they’re also very in tune with their place in this world, and the absolute necessity to pursue this dream with the right motivation. The “fame drug” was mentioned, and it can affect every move these artists make, at every stage of the process.

I hear music from another room. That’s not that unusual. What is unusual is that I’m not sure if it’s being played from a CD as background music or if the artist is right there, performing, here in the middle of the day at a convention center.

Turns out it is the actual artist, Bluetree, performing the actual song, “God of This City.” I’m supposed to see them tonight at Rocketown. I’ve only been here four and a half hours, and I’m already just flying.