What your favorite U2 song says about you February 25, 2009
Posted by markgeil in Music.Tags: U2
15 comments
I thought I was just entering a contest. I enter contests all the time, and I sometimes even win. This was an entry to fly to NY next week to see U2 perform on Letterman. Cool prize, I thought, as I hit the website to enter.
Then the entry form gave me pause. In the spirit of Letterman’s Top Ten lists, the form asked for my Top Ten U2 songs. Now, I knew the list was essentially meaningless since it did not affect my chances of winning, and might not even be looked at by anyone ever. Why, then, did I spend the next several minutes agonizing over my list? Because lists are the windows to the soul, that’s why!
If you’re not a U2 fan, you may stop reading now. If you are, perhaps you’ll share some of my consternation. The spaces on the entry form started with #1, presumably my favorite U2 song of all. Of course, this response basically defines me as a person, so I take it very seriously. I see a few different categories of people, based on their response to just this first blank:
The “Vertigo” person. Casual fan, knows the song from the iPod commercial, probably rather young. Would enjoy the trip to NYC more than the U2 performance. Might even skip out on Letterman to do more shopping or sightseeing.
The “With or Without You” person. Thinks, rightly, that Joshua Tree was one of the greatest albums ever. Maybe even saw a concert on that tour. A rather spiritual person who can’t let go of 80’s music, and let’s face it, who can’t? Thought, at some point, that U2 was the greatest band ever. Maybe still thinks that. This person is freaking out about how old he’s getting.
The “Sunday Bloody Sunday” person. Thinks “new” U2 is lame compared to “old” U2. Denies that Zooropa even exists. Listens to lots of classic rock on the radio. Also likes Rush, and Pink Floyd, and The Who. Once owned a guitar, but might not have ever learned to play it.
The “One” person. Idealist. Activist. Admires Bono’s efforts at poverty relief and social justice. Democrat, or possibly Canadian. Thought the exuberant Mary J. Blige cover of this song was stellar. Likes coffee.
The “Numb” person. Thinks everyone else is a poseur and wants to use this selection to show that he is fully aware of the more obscure songs in a band’s repertoire. Knows the exact date when each of his favorite bands became a sell-out. Owns a bootleg of the Passengers fake movie soundtrack and thinks it’s better than any U2 studio album.
The “Get On Your Boots” person. Knows what’s current. Will buy the new album as soon as it’s released, and might have even pre-ordered it, but will then only listen to it for a couple of weeks before moving on to the next big thing. Has read about the connection of Eno, Lanois, and Lillywhite to the new album, but couldn’t tell you who Eno, Lanois, or Lillywhite are.
The “40″ person. A U2 connoisseur. Remembers, vividly, walking out of an arena singing “How long, to sing this song?” with thousands of others in a surreal moment of harmonic convergence. Likes new U2 as much as old U2, and owns every album, except for maybe Pop. Has a copy of the video for New Year’s Day on VHS. Knows why the song is called “40″.
At least, that’s what I was thinking as I settled on the last choice, “40″, as my #1 U2 song. I know I’ve just described myself as pretty much awesome, but that’s what I want that choice to say about me. Now pity me as you realize I had NINE other selections to make! I picked a few of the above, added “Bad”, “Beautiful Day”, and even “Sometimes You Can’t Make It On Your Own”, which takes forever to type. Now I’m hoping the contest organizers actually look at everyone’s entry, and choose based on awesomeness. I’d win for sure.

Stay Married February 16, 2009
Posted by markgeil in Awana.add a comment
I passed a new billboard today. It said something like, “For the Children, Get Married. Stay Married.” This week, I couldn’t agree more. I had a wonderful Valentine ’s Day with my wife and children. A few days before that, I learned about a few more families being torn apart, or in some cases tearing themselves apart. I was the speaker in a room full of 70 Awana kids between Kindergarten and Second Grade. I spoke about love, trying to explain to children so young that agape love means God loves us all the time, everywhere, no matter what. I mentioned without great emphasis that some of the kids in the room have probably had times in their lives when they’ve felt unloved, only half believing it to be true. I finished and dismissed the kids, and a little line formed in front of me. The first kid in the little line said, “My aunt uncle are getting divorced.”
Another kid said, “I have a sister but she lives far away. I’ve never even seen her before.”
Still another said, “My mom and dad got in a big fight, and mom went to stay with my grandma.”
I know each of these kids, but I had no idea. I know the mom, and the dad. I’m not sure why my talk elicited these stories, but they blindsided me. What broke my heart the most was the way these kids were communicating. They weren’t in tears. Far from it. They could have just as well been telling me about what happened on TV the night before. They were either throwing up some sort of defense mechanism that renders such trauma somehow… conversational, or they were so accustomed to the notions of divorce and separation that they were resigned to it as some inevitability. God, I hope we are not that far gone.
For the children, please, stay married.
Black Diamond Triumph February 16, 2009
Posted by markgeil in Family.Tags: skiing
1 comment so far
We went skiing this weekend. None of the girls had been before, but they all learned quickly and after a few hours had mastered the chair lift, the “green circle” beginner slope, and the snowplow. Later, Sarah and Hannah had moved up to the intermediate “blue square” slopes. By about 9:00 that night, when the sun had set and the slushy snow had started to freeze over, Sarah and Hannah decided their day would not be complete unless they at least attempted a “black diamond” slope. So, up we went, all the way to the top of the mountain, to stand at the edge of the “Upper Omigosh”. The thing with downhill skiing is, you can’t really “attempt” a trail and then change your mind halfway down. And halfway down was when Hannah wanted to change her mind.
Her motivation was timeless: she refused to let a certain boy best her. Owen had skied a black diamond; therefore, she must. On the steep hill, skis scraping on the ice, in the nastiest of conditions, that motivation faded. The snowplow just wasn’t doing it, she kept falling, and her big sister was already halfway down the slope. She even declared, “This was not worth it!” But when you’re stuck on the middle of a hill, and you can’t really climb back up, you just have to keep going. So she did.
We got her skis back on after another fall, and just as she popped up an equally novice snowboarder almost crashed into us, essentially giving her a sizeable push down the hill. She scraped over the ice in her snowplow, rapidly picking up speed, and somehow failing to turn. Here’s the thing: any skier knows that turning slows you down and going straight speeds you up. Hannah was going decidedly straight.
Here’s the other thing: when you’re only a few hours from Atlanta, you can’t count on a lot of snow. The slope we were on had a decent base of mostly machine-made snow, but everywhere else was barren forest. So, the edges of the slopes were sheer 80-inch drop-offs, straight into the barren, rocky, forest. With lots of rocks. And trees. That’s what Hannah was skiing toward. Faster, and faster, and faster.
I yelled, “HANNAH! TURN! NOW!” as I skied toward her as fast as I could. With no more than two feet to spare, she did not turn, but instead fell into the ice hard enough to stop herself before she fell over the edge. Whew. I caught up to her, gave her a little lecture about the edges and their impending doom, and she gamely got back up and managed a few icy snowplow turns between crashes, eventually making it all the way down.
She was still not sure if it was all worth it until the following happened. Amy was calling a friend, catching up on the weekend. Classmate boy who motivated the near-death experience happened to be in the friend’s garage. Friend stepped out and said, “Hey Owen, guess what? Hannah Geil did a black diamond run.” Owen paused, looked down a little, and said in disgust, “Dangit.” That made it all worth it.
Happy to be wrong February 16, 2009
Posted by markgeil in Music.Tags: Bebo Norman, Britney Spears
add a comment
I mentioned in this space that a song called “Britney” by Bebo Norman would not make it on the radio, based on the sample chosen for audience testing on Fish stations. I’m happy to report that I was wrong, as I’m listening to the song right now on Way-FM. Good for Bebo!
Now, in the category of the ironic, I wonder how many people will visit this post just because it’s tagged with Britney’s name.
Review: CompassionArt February 11, 2009
Posted by markgeil in Music, Reviews.Tags: Chris Tomlin, CompassionArt, Darlene Zschech, Israel Houghton, Martin Smith, Matt Redman, Michael W. Smith, Steven Curtis Chapman
2 comments

There are lots of different types of music fans. There are “background noise” fans, who like to have music on but couldn’t tell you the name of the last song they heard. There are crazed teenage fans who remind us that the term is short for “fanatic”, the ones who know everything there is to know about their culture’s latest craze: Elvis and Beatles then, JoBros now, plenty in between. Then there are the fans of music itself, who appreciate the craft and construction of a song, who understand both the intellectual and visceral responses to lyrics and melodies. The CompassionArt project should appeal to these people, whether they like the music or not.
Finally released this past month, the CD/DVD and companion book are the fruits of a dozen songwriters and even more performers in an effort to raise funds for charities directed at poverty relief all over the world. Martin Smith is the father of this project, moved by the plight of the “least of these” he encountered in his travels.
The CompassionArt “experiment” was a brave and audacious venture, and fans of the craft of music will be mesmerized. On the surface, CompassionArt is a multi-artist benefit CD. The phrase itself conjures recollections of Band Aid’s “Do They Know it’s Christmas” or USA for Africa’s “We are the World”, and the parade of lesser-heralded mega-collaborations like “Voices That Care”, or “Sun City,” or even “Hands Across America”. (I should get some kind of award for remembering “Hands Across America”.) The profound differences are these: CompassionArt is a full album, not a single song, and CompassionArt was written by a dozen artists – not one song per artist, but a true collaboration of some of the most well-known Christian musicians alive today.
Set in a corporate retreat center during a damp and chilly Scotland winter, CompassionArt saw the birth of songs as an exercise in group dynamics, community, and corporate worship. A flip-chart on an easel, a staple of any corporate retreat, bore the names of songwriting “dream teams”, and each team was given a simple assignment: go away for two hours, develop a song, and come back and share it with the group. This is my favorite part of the documentary. The dozen participants’ names are all over the CCLI top 25. They’re the 3-part names everyone knows, like Michael W. Smith and Steven Curtis Chapman. They’re the surnames we shouldn’t be able to pronounce but we do, because they’ve produced so much, like Baloche and Zschech and Houghton. A set of a few names scrawled on a flip chart became a two-hour get-together including the aforementioned 3-part-name-guys. The last few minutes of that two hour get-together (after the requisite catching up) became the birth of the song “Highly Favoured”. That song was vetted among the entire group, a process that saw the delicate lyrics avoid crossing the border into egocentricity, and eventually became a performance by what remains the most compelling duet in Christian music, Michael W. Smith and Amy Grant. That the songwriters, publishers, and labels would both give away all royalties to these songs forever, and that the writers would in so many cases give away their performances to guest vocalists, attests to the common goal of poverty relief and the sense of community in which these songs were nurtured.
The “work on a song for a couple of hours and then hash it out among the group” process was repeated over and over in week’s time. The flip chart revealed new combinations of names each time, and the list of songs grew to over twenty. A few weeks later the best fifteen songs were recorded at Abbey Road Studios, with the help of guest performers including Grant, TobyMac, Leeland Mooring, and Kirk Franklin.
I love these songs. They are disjointed, and eclectic, and it turns out most of them are not well-suited for corporate worship, but they absolutely hold up to multiple spins of the CD, and they stay in my head for days, in a good way. Some will stand out for you, and they’ll be different from the ones that stand out for me, and that’s a testament to the craft of the songs. I have a few specific comments: The TobyMac/Kirk Franklin offering “Let it Glow” is an utterly misplaced 2-minute interlude where none was needed. I still like it, just not here. I never realized it until I heard him among this cavalcade of so many voices, but Leeland sounds a lot like Phil Keaggy. I wish MWS would have sung a bit more on his duet with AG. He’s relegated to a backup role, so the effect of the duet is lessened. There’s a scene in the DVD in which Martin Smith talks about a few small issues with egos during the week. It might be that dry British wit, but I’m really not sure if he’s serious or not. I can’t imagine egos not flaring up over the course of a week like this with people like these who care about music and its message, and for whom songs are like children.
If you’re in that third category of music fans (the music snobs), watch the DVD first. Watch the songs being born, and then listen to the finished product, and then watch the DVD a second time. Even if you’re in that first category (background music fan), buy the CD and play it as background music. You’ll be helping a bunch of worthy causes.
Finally, if you’re so inclined, lyrics and chord charts are available for free at:
Review: Winter Jam Tour 2009 February 9, 2009
Posted by markgeil in Music.Tags: Brandon Heath, Grammy, Hawk Nelson, Newsong, TobyMac, Winter Jam
1 comment so far
Here’s a first for me: attending a concert on the very night the headliner receives a Grammy Award. The award was best Rock or Rap Gospel Album, and the headliner who won that award was TobyMac. (Just how screwed up are the Grammy categories for Christian music, anyway? Rock or Rap?) The concert was Winter Jam, an eclectic mash-up of acts on a tour hosted by Newsong, for whom this Atlanta show was essentially a homecoming.
New Gotee artist Stephanie Smith opened the evening in a resplendent pink tutu. Note to new artists trying to build name recognition: pink tutus are effective, but only if one has the musical chops to back up the sartorial bravado. Fortunately Stephanie does. Here’s what had me reeling about her 4-song set: two dissonant back-to-back firsts in my concert-going career, from this diminutive opening act. Both happened at the end of the set. The first was an explosion of silly string into the first 8 rows apparently from Smith’s gloved right hand. I gotta get me one of them gloves. The second has me reevaluating what I thought I knew about concert gimmicks. Out of nowhere (to close a set during which the house lights were still up, for crying out loud!) Smith unleashed the FLAMING MIC STAND! The flames started about halfway up and ascended the stand all the way to the mic itself! Is this something all the cool kids have now? I’ve seen Robert Plant, people! I’ve seen Rush, and U2, and Yes, and plenty of bands with pyro in their sets. How is it that I’ve never seen the flaming mic stand before? And how is it that the first time I see it it’s from a girl in a pink tutu? My world has been rocked.
Smith was followed by PureNRG, who sang and danced with their usual gusto. Any readers who followed my old blog will recall my adventures with these kids around downtown Atlanta a couple of years ago. They seem to be doing well and got an enthusiastic reception from the now-full floor seat crowd. The stage seemed a bit cramped for their dancing and flipping antics, but they danced and flipped gamely nonetheless and got the crowd hoppin’.
Francesca Battistelli followed, and I had the following question. If I’m a new artist who has had one song make some serious airplay penetration in a given market, and I’m going to play four songs in a concert in that market, when do I play my one hit? The obvious choice is last, so you can build up to it and everyone will cheer loudly. Battistelli chose the other logical choice: play the song, “I’m Letting Go”, first, so that everyone in the crowd can put a face with a name, as it were, and then associate the remaining three songs with you as well. A good choice, since she followed with three excellent tunes. She has a recognizable voice that’s just different enough that methinks she’ll do well.
The hosts Newsong were next. On-screen lyrics were appreciated, as was the passionate performance of “Arise, My Love”. Yes, the guys are getting a little long in the tooth, and yes, the vocals are going the way of Audio Adrenaline, but that song made me want to fast forward straight to Easter! Then, from long in the tooth to, well, short in the tooth?, Hawk Nelson took over the stage, nay, the whole arena. The speakers were too loud, so the vocals were too muddled, but that always seems to be the case with these dudes. Nonetheless, the show was wildly entertaining, with good representation from the latest album, including the expected Bring ‘Em Out and Friend Like That, and a few treats in Ancient History, Let’s Dance, and One Little Miracle. Hawk Nelson is still my friend.
After the HN set came another of the show’s lengthy breaks. I know that set changes had to take some time, but on the whole there were too many pauses in the action at Winter Jam. There were really loud commercials between each act, an appeal to help orphans until they are adopted through Holt International, a presentation of the Gospel and an invitation, a protracted love offering, and a couple of other mini-sermons and announcements. These were all no doubt important, but many ran just a bit too long, and the whole pace could have been tightened considerably.
I’ve got a soft spot for singer-songwriters, and I had therefore been looking forward to the next act, Brandon Heath. Heath was nominated for a Grammy as well, but lost to Kirk Franklin, costing us a rare double-artist win that would have allowed me to call the concert “Grammy East”. I think I might call it that anyway. He was sandwiched between Hawk Nelson and TobyMac, providing a welcome musical intermezzo during which we could actually understand the words of the songs! Heath has two major hits, so he was able to open with one, I’m Not Who I Was, and close with the other, Give Me Your Eyes. In between, he played Wait and See and Love Never Fails, both from his new album. The latter was sparse and piercing and beautifully delivered, and received applause equal to any of the bombast that surrounded it.
Finally, the remarkable Diverse City band took the stage just before their patriarch and Grammy Award Winner, TobyMac. I’ve never been disappointed by a TobyMac show, and this was no exception. The energy never waned for even a moment as the band pounded out hit after hit and included the requisite trampoline jumps, freestyle raps, and beatboxing. I particularly enjoyed a sequence of tunes utterly lost on the teenagers in the house, including a disco medley with perfect placement of “Play that Funky Music” during the decidedly Caucasian lead guitarist’s solo. As Toby tore through songs like Boomin’, Made To Love, Lose My Soul, One World, The Slam, and J Train, I was a little taken aback by just how vast his repertoire has become.
There’s a lot to like about Winter Jam. Tickets are only $10, and while I don’t really like general admission, it does mean that dedicated fans at a show like this can sit way down front for a relative pittance. There’s a good sense of community among the artists, and a few familiar faces even came out to the show just to watch, including Newsong alumnus Russ Lee and Third Day’s Mac Powell. I was entertained for hours, as were thousands of others, but more than that the message of the Good News was clear.
I have an interview with Aaron Shust tomorrow. I’ll post leftovers if I have them.
Reviews on the way February 9, 2009
Posted by markgeil in Music.add a comment
Thanks for the good discussion on first albums. I’m writing several reviews that I can’t seem to find the time to finish, but stay tuned. Later this morning I’ll post a recap of the Winter Jam concert from last night. Then, look for a review of the new long-anticipated CompassionArt project.